For many Canadian charities, GivingTuesday on December 1 brings in the largest group of new donors of the year, most of whom the organization knows very little about.

The day keeps growing in Canada. CanadaHelps reported that more than $16 million was donated through its platform alone on GivingTuesday 2025, and many of those donors give to an organization for the first time. The day also raises the profile of philanthropy and the work charities do. What matters is what happens to those donors after the thank you email goes out.

The default path

At most organizations, every GivingTuesday donor gets the same acknowledgement and then waits for next year’s appeal. Few of them hear from you in a way that reflects who they actually are, and a handful of them could have been major gift prospects.

An example

Consider a charity that receives $100,000 from 2,000 new donors on GivingTuesday. In January, it screens those donors.

These figures are illustrative; capacity ranges estimate potential and don’t predict future giving.

DonorsEstimated five year giving capacity
10$500,000 and up
90$250,000 to $500,000
300$100,000 to $250,000
1,600Up to $100,000

The top 100 donors, 5% of the group, are reviewed and qualified for the major gift pipeline. After careful cultivation and stewardship, suppose 10 of them make a major gift averaging $10,000. That’s a small fraction of their combined capacity, and it adds $100,000 from one segment, doubling the value of the day.

Four step flow: new GivingTuesday donors, screen and segment in January, major gifts, monthly giving and stewardship, lasting relationships

The other segments matter too. Engaged donors in the middle tiers are good candidates for monthly giving and upgrade asks.

Timing matters

Screen in January, while the first gift is still recent and a personal thank you call still feels natural. A donor who first hears from you the following fall is much harder to reach in a meaningful way.

Screening and segmenting your GivingTuesday donors in January is the most reliable way to turn a single day of giving into lasting relationships.

Learn more about donor screening with CharityCAN, or read our Guide to Donor Screening.

Ready to get started with CharityCAN?